FACTS: Kaima, Pambie and Nikki took the bar exams. The Mercantile Law exam had an item on Intellectual Property law regarding copyright of a rap song entitled Warm Warm Honey by Mocha Warm. However, particular riffs of the song were found out to be from Under Hassle, a song by Majesty, a British rock band prominently featuring Fredo Uranus as its lead singer. Majesty sued Mocha Warm but the same was settled out of court. The three bar examinees were driven to madness by the difficulty of the exam and wrote a poem inspired by the question on intellectual property law. The particular lines and their authors are indicated below.
Questions and Suggested Answers:(Kaima) Warm, warm honey
it's a mystery
boiling point is 120
bagay na bagay sa iced tea.
(Nikki) Ihalo sa coffee
para siguradong wakie wakie
(Pambie) puwede rin sa kamikaze
at sawsawan ng berry
(Pambie) Galing sa bee
na mahilig habulin si Pambie
Warm, Warm, HoneyBreak it down Baby, Yeah!
1. Who owns the copyright of the poem?
2. Where will Kaima get her royalty? Is it taxable? at what rate?
Alternative Answer: Kaima will not get her royalty anywhere but it will be taxable because taxes are the lifeblood of the government.
3. Suppose that Nikki shoved a bee and the bee stung Pambie causing her death, who is criminally liable? What crime/s was committed?
Nobody is criminally liable because shoving the bee is not a felony, or a crime for that matter. Under Article 4 of the Revised Penal Code, a person is liable for the crime committed and all its natural and logical consequences. Shoving a bee is not a crime hence, there is no felony.
Alternative Answer: Murder was committed, through the qualifying circumstance of cruelty because the sting of a bee is very painful hence inflicting unnecessary pain upon Pambie. However, nobody is criminally liable because Nikki was insane at the time she shoved the bee as no person in his or her right mind would shove a bee.
Bonus Question: Is the Supreme Court entitled to any royalties? If so, how much? Feel free to invent a legal basis.
Song of the Hour: Heart of the Matter (by India Arie but originally by Don Henley-- who owns the copyright?)



huling hirit bago mag-september





